Gillette Stadium
Finished 2 - 2 (AP)
(FT: 1 - 1)
(HT: 1 - 1)
Penalty Shootout: 3 - 5
| | | 3 |  | Rodriguez Santiago |
| Buksa Adam |  | 9 | | |
| | | 18 |  | Castellanos Valentin |
| Polster Matt |  | 27 | | |
| Buksa Adam |  | 54 | | |
| | | 58 |  | Rodriguez Santiago |
| | | 82 |  | Rocha Tony |
| | | 84 |  | Morales Alfredo |
| Ingvi Traustason Arnor |  | 91 | | |
| Maciel |  | 91 | | |
| | | 101 |  | Thorarinsson Gudmundur |
| | | 101 |  | Thiago |
| | | 109 |  | Castellanos Valentin |
| | | 113 |  | Castellanos Valentin |
| Boateng Emmanuel |  | 114 | | |
| Bunbury Teal |  | 114 | | |
| | | 118 |  | Tajouri-shradi Ismael |
| Buchanan Tajon |  | 118 | | |
| | | 2221 |  | Morales Alfredo (Pen) |
| Gil Carles (Pen) |  | 2221 | | |
| | | 2222 |  | Thiago (Pen) |
| Buksa Adam (Miss) |  | 2222 | | |
| | | 2223 |  | Tajouri-shradi Ismael (Pen) |
| Bunbury Teal (Pen) |  | 2224 | | |
| | | 2225 |  | Moralez Maxi (Pen) |
| Jones Dejuan (Pen) |  | 2225 | | |
| | | 2225 |  | Callens Alexander (Pen) |
| New England |
| 2 | Andrew Farrell |
| 4 | Henry Kessler |
| 7 | Gustavo Bou |
| 8 | Matt Polster |
| 9 | Adam Buksa |
| 15 | Brandon Bye |
| 17 | Tajon Buchanan |
| 22 | Carles Gil |
| 24 | DeJuan Jones |
| 26 | Tommy McNamara |
| 30 | Matt Turner |
| 5 | Wilfrid Kaptoum |
| 10 | Teal Bunbury |
| 11 | Emmanuel Boateng |
| 12 | Justin Rennicks |
| 13 | Lucas Maciel Felix |
| 18 | Brad Knighton |
| 23 | Jon Bell |
| 25 | Arnor Traustason |
| 28 | A.J. DeLaGarza |
| New York City |
| 1 | Sean Johnson |
| 4 | Maxime Chanot |
| 6 | Alexander Callens |
| 7 | Alfredo Morales |
| 10 | Maxi Moralez |
| 11 | Valentin Castellanos |
| 12 | Malte Amundsen |
| 16 | James Sands |
| 19 | Jesus Medina |
| 24 | Tayvon Gray |
| 42 | Santiago Rodriguez |
| 8 | Thiago |
| 9 | Heber |
| 13 | Luis Barraza |
| 15 | Tony Rocha |
| 17 | Ismael Tajouri |
| 20 | Gudmundur Thorarinsson |
| 21 | Andres Jasson |
| 23 | Gedion Zelalem |
| 43 | Talles Magno |
| New England | AP | New York City |
| 4 | No. Substitutions | 4 |
| 43 | Possession | 57 |
| 4 | Shots on Target | 4 |
| 7 | Shots off Target | 9 |
| 5.5 | Shots Per Goal | 6.5 |
| 2 | Shots Blocked | 3 |
| 11 | Attempts on Goal | 13 |
| 2 | Saves | 2 |
| 4 | Corners | 4 |
| 20 | Free Kicks | 22 |
| 13 | Goal Kicks | 19 |
| 22 | Fouls | 18 |
| 0 | Offsides | 2 |
New England v New York City Highlights